Who Decides the Arbitrator’s Jurisdiction in International Commercial Arbitration: The Competence-Competence Doctrine from a Transnational Perspective
Summary
The contractual character of international arbitration raises the question of who has the final word when a party challenges the arbitral tribunal’s jurisdiction. The paper examines the competence-competence doctrine, which allows the tribunal to rule on its own jurisdiction, together with the elements of the arbitration agreement and the separability principle, under the UNCITRAL Model Law and the New York Convention.
While the positive effect of the doctrine is widely recognised, its negative effect, namely at what stage and how intensively courts review a jurisdictional objection, differs across jurisdictions. The paper compares the prima facie review approach under Article 8(1) of the Model Law with French, English and US practice.
It concludes that courts should limit themselves to a prima facie review in order to prevent dilatory tactics and reduce costs; that English and US practice leave wider room for judicial control; and that French law, by giving the tribunal express priority, embraces the negative effect most consistently.